Forced Into Immigration Enforcement, A County Considers Plan B

When a single-mother of three got into a car accident while driving without a license in Hayward, California, she met a fate common to undocumented immigrants.

“A police officer told me he needed to take me to the police department where my fingerprints would be taken, said the woman, who shared her story with Deportation Nation by way of Somos Mayfair, but asked to remain anonymous.

While she was at the jail, Immigration and Customs Enforcement (ICE) agents saw her prints in the state DOJ database. She now faces deportation and the question of what to do with her children, who are all US citizens.

Stories like this have become common, but counties that feel forced into the data-sharing partnership called Secure Communities are exploring ways to avoid them. A key place to watch is Santa Clara, a California county of 1.8 million, where a third of residents are foreign-born.


Santa Clara County, San Fransisco County, CA and Arlington County, VA have sent letters formally requesting to opt-out of Secure Communities. (Click to view larger image.)

Even though Secure Communities has a mandate to target dangerous immigrants, recent data available for Santa Clara County shows non-criminals account for 26 percent of those transferred into ICE custody, and 34 percent of those deported. (see graph)

This rubs salt in the wounds of Santa Clara officials, who made it clear to ICE that it wasn’t interested in the program but got enrolled anyway this past May.

So shortly after Homeland Security Napolitano told reporters, “we do not view this as an opt-in, opt-out program,” the county went ahead and sent its opt-out letter. Now a meeting with ICE to discuss the request is scheduled for November 9.

In the meantime, Santa Clara’s Board of Supervisors has asked the county counsel to look into other possible actions.

“I think some local governments are starting to feel painted into a corner. We don’t want to have to make our own determination about who is worthy of being held for ICE and who is not,” said Anjali Bhargava, Deputy Counsel for Santa Clara County.

Bhargava is researching whether the county can ensure that “funds are only used to comply with requests by U.S. Immigration and Customs Enforcement to the extent they are subject to reimbursement or required by law.” This would apply only to the Sheriff and Probation departments, but not to the 15 city police departments in the county.

On a recent day the county’s Department of Corrections held 375 immigrants in its jail at the request of ICE, most of whom would be held the full 48 hours before federal agents picked them up. This means it could incur the costs of an additional 18,000 hours of detention, none of which would be covered by ICE.

Other counties have looked for ways to put limits on the fingerprints sent to the state’s database, which is monitored by ICE. This has been done in El Paso County, Texas, where the sheriff says he only shares fingerprints from Class B misdemeanors and above. This may not be allowed by California Penal Code.

But one thing county officials can control, is their budget. Depending on how ICE responds to its concerns, Santa Clara County may refuse to spend county resources detaining people on ICE’s request.

“That option is certainly still on the table,” said Bhargava.

Editor’s note: This story has been updated for clarity.

7 Responses to “Forced Into Immigration Enforcement, A County Considers Plan B”
  1. Dave A says:

    If money is the issue then counties should fine the aliens to offset the costs.

  2. Donna H. says:

    the Secure Communities program has actually had the effect of increasing lawlessness. I know of an undocumented family in which the husband has volunteered at his sons’ school and the mother has done volunteer work re health education. They are involved in their church; in short, they are good community members. Recently their landlord raised the rent on their apartment and they moved. I helped them clean up afterwards, and know they left it clean; but their landlord refused to return any of their security deposit. They’re afraid to take her to small claims court because they don’t want to risk getting caught as undocumented. So the landlord gets away with breaking the law.

    Their sister recently was in a similar situation, of a landlord refusing to return a deposit after she’d been in her apartment a week; she had to move because of a crazy woman upstairs who screamed through the night. The landlord had to know about that; when she called the police they said they’d been there before. Yet she was afraid to make demands on him.

    If the main concern of the feds is protecting us, why don’t they just deport those who wind up with criminal convictions? –As it is, the undocumented will be afraid of any involvement with the police; more crimes will go unreported, and lawlessness by those willing to exploit others will increase.

  3. Thus we became noobs on the water when we purchased our 1957
    If you are a foreigner unlikely to return if allowed to leave, you will not be able to post a bond.

    my website … crock pot freezer meals healthy

  4. Corporate Taxes: All business structures pay taxes on the income
    made in that particular business. Outsourcing accounting services for small business owners
    is workable for those who want to turn their focus on their companies and find a way
    to maximise their profitability. You would possibly make an sum
    of cash similar to a consequence of the Regional group.

    Here is my weblog … Boca Raton Cpa Supplies Canada

  5. Even frequent blow-drying at extreme heat or brushing obsessively can cause your hair to become extremely fragile causing
    it to break and fall out. main light based permanent hair removal technique for men. Remember, the foaming action of regular shampoos and detergents is
    for looks only.

    my web blog laser capsulotomy definition

  6. Your syndicate agreement does not have to be a complex document.
    Methods for baiting a hook – Step 5: Use them for fishing.
    Freshwater fish can be placed in the live well on the boat, or on a stringer to keep it
    alive until you are able to clean it.

    my webpage deck design examples

Check out what others are saying...
  1. […] jails to track undocumented immigrants who are accused or convicted of crimes. The program has come under fire from immigrants rights groups, as well as San Francisco’s Board of Supervisors and county […]

Leave A Comment