Is it really possible to opt-out of Secure Communities?

Last Thursday federal officials released a memo called “Setting the Record Straight” that outlines for the first time how local police can opt-out of sharing arrest data with immigration authorities via enrollment in the “Secure Communities” program. But so far, the process exists only on paper.

The memo from Immigration and Customs Enforcement (ICE) states:

All of these steps sounded familiar to San Francisco County Sheriff Michael Hennessey, except the resolution.

“I did all of that,” he said after reading the explanation.

When California signed a statewide agreement with ICE, Hennessey sent a letter to ICE on June 3 asking for his jurisdiction to opt-out of the program which allows agents to access arrest data from local jails.

Deputy Director for Secure Communities, Marc Rapp, responded to Hennessey with a phone call, the upshot of which was that there was no way his request could be granted. Shortly afterward, Secure Communities went into effect over the objection of the sheriff and his Board of Supervisors.

“I followed procedure, but they did not follow procedure,” said Hennessey.

Now the sheriff has sent another letter, this time asking California Attorney General, Jerry Brown, to clarify whether San Fransisco can stop sending its misdemeanor arrest data to ICE.

Confusion over how to opt-out of Secure Communities may explain how ICE has enrolled 574 jurisdictions in 30 states since it began two years ago. While the new memo suggests Secure Communities is voluntary, it definitely seemed mandatory when Orange County, North Carolina tried to opt-out in January 2009.

“My first reaction to the memo was that this is a complete contradiction to everything they said before,” said Marty Rosenbtlath, staff attorney with the Southern Coalition for Social Justice.

Rosenblath is a member of Orange County’s Human Rights commission, which was asked to investigate Secure Communities.

“We were told point blank by ICE that the only way for Orange County to opt-out was to stop fingerprinting people,” he said.

As a result, the county passed a resolution with the following request:

Now Rosenbluth says he plans to revisit the opt-out issue with the commission and the sheriff.

“At our next meeting we’re going to say, ‘Excuse us, we have this new information,” said Rosenbluth. “Would you mind please considering it?”

In counties already enrolled in Secure Communities, the push back is coming from both activists and local officials. Members of the New Sanctuary Movement in Philadelphia plan to ask the mayor to reconsider opting out. County Supervisors in Santa Clara, California may pass a resolution opposing the program.

Civil rights groups who filed an open records request with ICE in part to clarify the opt-out process say the agency’s next step should be to include similar instructions in agreements with states yet to be enrolled.

“We demand a clear protocol be included in every single Secure Communities agreement,” said Sarahi Uribe with the National Day Labor Organizing Network and lead organizer of the “Uncover The Truth Behind ICE and Police Collaborations” campaign.

Governors in Colorado and Washington could decide as soon as this week whether they will sign an agreement to enroll their states in Secure Communities. If they choose to join, local law enforcement agencies in those states could unleash a wave of opt-out requests that will put ICE’s new explanation to the test.

The agency is already on the hot seat back in San Fransisco. ICE spokesman, Richard Rocha, told the Washington Independent he will discuss Sheriff Hennessey’s new request to opt-out and seek a resolution that may “change the jurisdiction’s activation status.”

Stay tuned…

10 Responses to “Is it really possible to opt-out of Secure Communities?”
  1. Reg825 says:

    Did you see the recent PBS report that highlighted how the so-called “Secure Communities Program” might actually be making our communites INsecure by endangering public safety? You can access the report (video) here:

  2. Avoid conditioners with sulfates and keep one protein based conditioner at hand
    whenever you experience excessive shedding, breakage and lost
    moisture. The US National Library of Medicine warns against ingesting this petroleum
    product. It must be protected well if the body is to be kept safe and
    healthy without any serious problems.

    my blog … top hair products for men with thick hair

  3. Water is your organic cleaner so you should always be effectively moisturized.
    In 2009, men undergoing some sort of cosmetic surgery procedure rose eight percent.
    They also exhibit a willingness to answer questions and to make a patient feel safe and comfortable.

    My web-site :: nose job jacksonville fl

  4. Anitra says:

    When someone writes an piece of writing he/she maintains
    the idea of a user in his/her mind that how a user
    can know it. So that’s why this article is outstdanding.


  5. alarmas says:

    Sin sorpresas en la cuota ni extras inesperados.
    Evalúa el incendio.

  6. Ideal sería que proyectos de suma importancia a lo largo
    del curso fueran analizados por un maestro externo, de esta manera
    se constataría el aprendizaje íntegro del alumno.

  7. Hosea says:

    Hello everybody, here every person is sharing these kinds of familiarity,
    thus it’s good to read tbis webpage, and I used to go to
    see this blog every day.

    My blog IC strategy (Hosea)

Check out what others are saying...
  1. […] late August, ICE clarified how local jurisdictions can request to opt-out of Secure Communities. It described the process in a […]

  2. […] recently asked “Is it Really Possible to Opt-Out of Secure […]

  3. […] The comment comes on the heals of two votes this week – by Arlington County, VA and Santa Clara County, CA – to opt-out of the controversial enforcement program. It could be seen as a blow to what immigrant advocates had welcomed as progress in pushing-back against the program. But some see it as an opportunity for clarifying the opt-out process. […]

Leave A Comment